|
|
"dB61TL"
2-Way
Transmission Line Monitors
Project, Text and
Images courtesy of Dave
Brown
A great sounding, simple, two-way, transmission line
loudspeaker that can be built for $200 a pair.
|
|
Overview
The idea for this design was inspired
by a visit to the home of Nelson Pass, owner, CEO, and chief designer
at Pass Labs. Nelson is well known for his current line extraordinary
Pass Labs amplifiers but many will recall his Zen amp, Son of Zen, the
A40 and many more designs which have been published over the years.
Nelson is also a fanatic DIYer and strong supporter of audio hobbyists
as is evidenced by the plethora of DIY amplifier projects available on
his website http://www.passlabs.com/. When
I visited Nelson's home, he demonstrated a speaker with a 9 ft. line
and, if I recall, a 6 inch woofer.
The most I remember is that
the design was very simple - basically a box with two dividers to
create the line.
It's hard to remember
because of all the other projects he had built and was in the process
of building throughout his house and workshop.
Mind boggling to say the
least!
|

|
Before you Begin
Note to potential builders: I've
received some feedback and questions recently about the dB61TL. Before you
decide to build this speaker, here are a couple of comments:
-
The enclosure is not as easy to
construct as it might look at first glance. It is helpful to have access
to a table saw/radial arm saw and to have some experience using a router
-- or have somebody helping who has. There is also some work involved in
getting the stuffing and acoustic foam installed and it may need to be
adjusted by listening.
-
The design goal of this, and most
transmission line speakers is, to produce bass which is non-resonant and
smooth. If you're looking for loud or hard kicking bass, this isn't the
correct design.
-
If you have any questions about
building the dB61TL, please e-mail me.
A note about transmission line bass:
The goal of a t-line system is to produce bass which is totally free of port
and box resonances. The result should be a very natural sound which is full
but not boomy. You may find that you prefer louder bass with more kick or
punch. If so, a vented design may be more to your liking and there are
several available which use the same drivers as the dB61TL.
Driver Selection
I'd been playing around with the
Parts Express/Dayton 6 ½ inch woofer for several projects. One was a vented
two-way project designed for and built as an employee project for at work.
This evolved into a W-T-W two-way floor standing design I built for my son.
These designs also used a new
tweeter from Parts Express - a 1 1/8 inch silk dome tweeter.
Both the woofer and tweeter worked
extremely well in those speakers and are still much in favor in an almost
cult-like following on the Parts Express discussion forum at http://www.Parts-Express.com/.
|
 |
Dayton 6-1/2" Woofer
PE Part Number 295-305
The Dayton import
series of treated cone drivers are developing quite a reputation for
having the best price/performance value available anywhere.
Non-pressed treated paper cones, ASV voice coils, vented pole pieces,
rubber surrounds, coated cloth dust caps, and excellent low frequency
performance are just some of the features you'll find on these quality
woofers.
Full
Specifications
|
|
|

|
Dayton 1-1/8"
Silk Dome Tweeter
PE Part Number 275-070
Clinically tested
and compared to Morel with amazingly similar results, this tweeter is
recommended for crossover points as low as 1800 Hz. That versatility,
along with its high performance to cost ratio, makes this one of the
most popular Dayton drivers.
Full
Specifications
Download Response Graphs (17K PDF)
Product
Review By Wayne Jaeschke
|
| The dB61TL was built as an off-shoot of
those other Dayton driver designs and used the same construction
techniques and crossover which was a first order, minimum component
design.
Unfortunately, the sound of
the T/L version was disappointing.
The bass shelved down below
about 400 Hz and the woofer resonances at the upper end of its range
gave the speaker a bright sound.
So, the T/L sat in the corner
of my garage for several months, gathering dust.
Then, thanks to Wayne
Jaeschke, one of expert
"gurus" on the Parts Express site, who, within a couple of
months had designed, built and posted three designs using these same
Dayton drivers, I decided to try some changes.
I used the crossover Wayne
designed for his "Dayton II" speaker project. That crossover is
essentially the design used here, the only difference being the addition
of 6 dB of baffle step compensation and a slight change in the tweeter
L-pad attenuation. |
|
 |
 |
|
Wayne's crossover helps solve problems with the
woofer's resonance in the 4000 to 5000 Hz range. It uses second
order slopes and a notch filter that helps with the resonance. I added
additional baffle compensation to bring the bass up to where the
response is essentially flat down to 25 Hz. With a transmission line
speaker, the ability exists to produce extended bass. However, the
output is, at least in this line, lower than bass produced in a vented
alignment. Additional compensation works well to elevate the bass
level and still provides high impedance allowing any amplifier to
operate with full power. The result is a speaker that is controlled
and stable yet retains a coherent image with full, tuneful bass, a
smooth midrange and a very acceptable treble response.
A new 275-070 tweeter, which will be supplied for orders from Parts
Express starting in September, 2001, incorporates a closed back and
added diaphragm damping. It can be used as a direct substitute for the
old tweeter utilizing the exitsting crossover, but a revised
crossover, designed by Wayne Jaeschke (shown below) has been optimized
to maintain constant phase alignment througout the crossover range. I
built the revised crossover and installed it at the same time I
relplaced the 275-070 with the new tweeter.
The new tweeter, with the revised crossover, will sound considerably
more clear with an airy quality distinctly different from the old
tweeter. The imaging is maintained while the level of detail is
increased by an order of magnitude. I should mention, however, that I
changed the tweeter and crossover at the same time. I didn't try the
new tweeter with the old crossover. It is possible that some of the
audible differences I experienced were due to the crossover change and
not just the tweeter. I did, however, install the new tweeter in
another pair of speakers, without changing the crossover, and there
was a noticeable and similar improvement in the high frequency
response. I should mention that the new tweeter's output sounds higher
that the old version and, for this reason, makes the overall tonal
balance of the speaker brighter. |
| The transmission line is 94 inches long -- from
the woofer to the terminus at the rear. If we include another 12"
from the rear to the front it makes the total acoustic line distance
106". The line tapers from 35 sq. in to 26 sq. in. -- a taper ratio
of 75%. |
|
 |
The response shown here was measured with a Real Time
Analyzer (RTA) and an inexpensive mike. I believe the response is valid below
about 2 KHz, but above that the roll off is likely due to the mike. The
measurements were taken in my living room, so there are certainly some other
errors.

The lower limit of the bass response shown in the graph
is 25 Hz because that's the lower limit of the RTA used for the
measurements. The response extends below 25 Hz, but, using my test setup, how
low it goes is unknown.
The following tables and drawings show
the parts list, enclosure part dimensions, and crossover layout and parts
list. The drivers, crossover components and accessories are available from www.Parts-Express.com.
|
Parts and Cost for One Speaker
|
|
Item
|
Quantity
|
Cost/Each
|
Price
|
| 6 1/2" Woofer |
1
|
$15.20
|
$15.20
|
| 1 1/8" Silk Dome Tweeter |
1
|
13.80
|
13.80
|
| 3/4" MDF, 4' by 8' Sheet |
1
|
18.55
|
18.55
|
| Polyfil Stuffing, 20 Ounce Bag |
1
|
2.89
|
2.89
|
| Terminal/Binding Posts Bi-Amp |
1
|
4.35
|
4.35
|
| Crossover Parts |
*
|
34.44
|
34.44
|
| Grille Cloth |
1/2 Yard
|
7.50
|
3.75
|
| Grille Guides, Small |
8
|
1.90
|
1.90
|
| Glue |
1/2 Bottle
|
4.00
|
2.00
|
| Spikes |
Set of 4
|
11.90
|
11.90
|
| |
|
Total
|
$108.78
|
| *Crossover parts for original
crossover. Alternate crossover totals to $30.47. |
Construction
Construction is easy, but there are a couple of tools
and techniques that will make it easier.
A router with a setup for cutting holes for
the drivers, i.e. a circle cutting jig, makes for a very smooth cutout,
although I used a 3 1/2" hole saw for the tweeter. 1/2 inch and 3/8
inch rabbeting bits will help to cut the flush mount rabbets. The technique
for that is to cut a hole 1 inch or ¾ inches smaller than the diameter of
the overall diameter of the speaker flange, then use the rabbeting bit to
cut the flush mount portion to the flange diameter. Set the depth to
correspond to the thickness of the speaker flange and the gasket or sealant
you'll use to mount the drivers.
Another technique for cutting holes that I like best of all involves the use
of templates. I cut the template so that it looks just like the hole I'm
trying to make in the speaker. Use 1/8" or 1/4" hardboard and a
jigsaw to cut the shape. Make sure to cut carefully and sand smooth since
the hole you cut in the speaker will be exactly like the template. Attach
the template to the baffle with a couple of screws and, using a 1/4"
router bit with bearing on the end, cut the hole. The bearing rides on the
edge of the template. Note, that this must be done before
the speaker is assembled. Also, it's almost a necessity to use a router
table for this since there won't be much surface for the router to ride on
near the edge of the baffle.
Another very useful technique is to cut the front, back , top, and bottom
slightly oversize (about 1/8" on each edge), then trim the overhang
after assembly. For this, a straight bit with bearing is needed.
I assembled the box using drywall screws and glue, but since have gone to
using finishing nails instead of screws.
It takes a little getting used to, but you
don't have to pre-drill and counter sink and you don't have the big
holes to fill.
dB61TL Schematics
Click the thumbnails below for full-sized schematics.
|
|

Overall View
|

Enclosure Parts (All parts ¾ MDF)
|
| |
|
|

Detailed Front/Rear Measurements
|

Enlarged Part Drawings
|
The Main Cabinet
Click Here for
Step-by-Step Cabinet Construction
|

|

|
Front and rear baffles -- driver cutouts with flush
mount rabbeting. On the left are the holes for the terminal cups
(upside down).
|
Cutting out the woofer hole using an aluminum
template and straight cutting bit with bearing. Router mounted in
router table.
|
| |
|
|

|

|
3/8" Rabbeting bit being used to cut woofer
flush mount, 5/16" deep. 1/2" bit (3/16" deep) is used
for the tweeter.
|
Assembly before
attaching right side panel.
|
| |
|
|

|

|
Terminus opening -- cut using inside edges and trim
pieces to guide router.
|
Rectangular dual terminal cup
which allows bi-wiring.
|
The Cabinet Base
Click Here for
Step-by-Step Base Construction
The base is very important. Combining the
speaker's narrow width with its height of 4 feet, it doesn't take much to
knock it over, especially on carpet. The base adds the needed width for
stability. It is also a place for the crossover. Use of the spikes is also
recommended.

|

Base from Bottom
|

Base with Bottom Open
|
Step
by Step Cabinet Construction
-
Cut all pieces to
the dimensions shown.
-
Cut driver cutouts
in front baffle and rabbet for flush mount.
-
Cut hole for
terminal cup in rear panel.
-
Cut 45 degree
bevels on interior reflectors.
-
Cut the two
terminus trim pieces with 45 degree bevels.
-
Lay out in pencil
the locations of the four reflectors and the divider on both side panels.
-
Glue the divider,
top, and bottom in place between the two sides.
-
Glue the four
reflectors in place.
-
Install foam
absorption material to the top reflectors and divider.
-
Install foam to
the inside of the front and rear panels.
-
Install triangular
piece "G" to top of reflector "C".
-
Install piece
"H" onto rear panel centered horizontally and at a point which
will be 4 1/4" below the lower edge of piece "G". Note,
these last two steps are done now so that the terminus can be cutout with
a router using "G", "H", and the sides as guides.
-
Glue the front
baffle and rear panel in place.
-
Cut out the
terminus opening.
-
Install the two
terminus opening trim pieces.
-
Drill wire hole in
bottom.
-
Paint or apply
veneer as desired.
-
Install wiring
from drivers out hole in bottom.
-
Install wiring
from terminal cup out hole in bottom.
-
Install drivers
and terminal cup.
-
Install base and
connect wiring to crossover.
Step by
Step Base Construction
-
Glue side pieces
to top of base.
-
Drill hole for
wires going into speaker.
-
Drill holes for
spikes.
-
Drill and
countersink holes to attach base to speaker.
-
Use ½"
rabbeting bit to cut recess for bottom panel.
-
Cut out bottom
panel to fit opening in bottom of base.
-
Pre-drill and
countersink holes to attach bottom panel to base.
-
Paint or apply
veneer to base.
-
Attach base to
bottom of speaker.
-
Install crossover
onto bottom panel and connect wires to drivers and terminal cup.
Wiring
It's best to install the
wiring after assembly and finishing, but before stuffing the line. Run a
pair of wires from each driver down and out through a 1/2" hole in the
bottom of the speaker, into the base. Run another pair from the terminal
binding posts down and out through the same hole. Leave about 16" extra
for each wire coming out the hole. Attach the wires to the crossover and
secure the bottom base cover.
Note: If you plan on bi-wiring, i.e., using two sets of binding posts and
splitting the crossover into separate tweeter and woofer sections, you will
need to include the baffle step filter (R4/L3) in each section. That's
because this filter operates on both drivers, over the entire frequency
range. However, for the tweeter section, all that is really needed is R4,
the 8 ohm resistor. L3, the 2.0 mH inductor, can be omitted since it
provides a low pass path at around 500 Hz.
Stuffing
I ended up using a
stuffing density of around .75 lbs/cu.ft. of Polyfil pillow stuffing. You
may have heard that this material is not the absolute best to use, but
it's inexpensive and readily available.
Finishing
Veneering is an easy
and, considering the time and effort involved in an well done painted
finish, an inexpensive option.
A 4' x 8' sheet will cost about
$60 for common paper-backed veneers such as oak and cherry.
You can buy them at
hardwood (woodworker) supply stores or from online suppliers such as http://www.woodveneers.com/.
Even if you've never veneered
before, it's not that hard.
You can then stain and apply a
gloss or semi-gloss finish that will look great.
You can also paint
the enclosure.
Depending on your experience and
the amount of time you want to devote to it, you can do a spray can job or
create a piano black gloss finish.
The Grille
Here is a drawing of
the grille.
It is made from ¾" MDF and
covered with black grille cloth.
Round over the inside and outside
edges of the side away from the speaker.
Before installing the grille
cloth, drill a small (1/16") hole where the grille guides will go, place
the grille on the speaker, and shove a small finishing nail or brad through
the hole to mark the front of the speaker.
Drill out the grille guide holes
then install the grille cloth with hot glue or staple it in place.
Crossover
Original Version
This crossover was developed by Wayne Jaeschke for his
Dayton II two-way, vented loudspeaker which used the original version of the
Dayton 275-070 tweeter. You may use it for the new version of the tweeter
also and it will work very well -- or you may want to build the revised
crossover which Wayne designed specifically to account for the
characteristics of the new tweeter.
Note that both crossover versions include an added 6dB of baffle step
compensation to account for the transmission line's shelf response.
Component Values for the
Original Crossover
|
COMPONENT
|
VALUE
|
DESCRIPTION
|
FUNCTION
|
|
L1
|
0.6
mH
|
18
ga. |
Tweeter
High Pass |
|
L2
|
0.82
mH
|
14
ga. |
Woofer
Low Pass |
|
L3
|
2.0
mH
|
20
ga. |
Baffle
Step Filter |
|
L4
|
0.33
mH
|
18
ga. |
Notch
Filter |
|
R1
|
8
ohm
|
10
W Wire Wound |
Tweeter
L-pad |
|
R2
|
16
ohm
|
10
W Wire Wound |
Tweeter
L-pad |
|
R3
|
8
ohm
|
10
W Wire Wound |
Zoebel
Impedance Compensation |
|
*R4
|
2
ohm
|
20
W Wire Wound |
Baffle
Step Filter |
|
R5
|
12
ohm
|
10
W Wire Wound |
Notch
Filter |
|
*R6 |
20 ohm |
10
W Wire Wound |
Baffle
Step Parallel |
|
C1
|
6.2
uF
|
Metallized
Polypropylene Cap |
Tweeter
High Pass |
|
C2
|
10
uF
|
Polypropylene |
Woofer
Low Pass |
|
C3
|
47
uF
|
Non-polarized
electrolytic |
Zoebel
Impedance Compensation |
|
C4
|
0.1
uF
|
Polypropylene |
Bypass |
|
C5
|
12
uF
|
Polypropylene |
Notch
Filter |
| *Revised
or added component |
New Crossover
Revised for the new generation 275-070
This alternate crossover was
developed by Wayne Jaeschke for the new production version of the Dayton
275-070 tweeter. The new tweeter is damped to provide a lower Fs and has an
overall smoother response as long as a response peak near the crossover
frequency is dealt with. The revised crossover also contains fewer
components.
R2, R3, and R4 provide
approximately 3dB of attenuation for the tweeter. You may adjust this L-Pad
to your liking or as necessary to account for how the speaker sounds in your
listening room. See the L-pad chart below which gives values of Rs and Rp
for different desired attenuation values. Note that R2 and R3 in this
crossover are 4 ohms and 6 ohms paralleled to arrive at 2.4 ohms for Rs.

Component
Values for the Revised Crossover
|
COMPONENT
|
VALUE
|
DESCRIPTION
|
FUNCTION
|
|
L1
|
0.3
mH
|
20
ga.
|
Tweeter
High Pass |
|
L2
|
0.33
mH
|
14
ga.
|
Woofer
Low Pass |
|
L3
|
2.0
mH
|
16
ga.
|
Baffle
Step Filter |
|
L4
|
0.4
mH
|
18
ga.
|
Notch
Filter |
|
R1
|
6
ohm
|
Non-inductive
|
Tweeter
High Pass |
|
R2
|
4
ohm
|
Non-inductive
|
L-Pad
Series |
|
R3
|
6
ohm
|
Non-inductive
|
L-Pad
Series |
|
R4
|
20
ohm
|
Non-inductive
|
L-Pad
Parallel |
|
*R5
|
2
ohm
|
20
Watt Ceramic
|
Baffle
Step Filter |
|
R6
|
30
ohm
|
Non-inductive
|
Notch
Filter |
|
R7
|
8
ohm
|
Non-inductive
|
Zoebel
Impedance Compensation |
| *R8 |
20
ohm |
10
Watt Ceramic |
Baffle
Step Filter Parallel |
|
C1
|
8.2
uF
|
Polypropylene
|
Tweeter
High Pass |
|
C2
|
6.8
uF
|
Polypropylene
|
Tweeter
High Pass |
|
C3
|
47
uF
|
Non-polarized
electrolytic
|
Zoebel
Impedance Compensation |
|
C4
|
0.1
uF
|
Polypropylene
|
Bypass |
|
C5
|
5
uF
|
Polypropylene
(3 uF+ 2 uF)
|
Notch
Filter |
| *Revised
or added components |
|
L-Pad Resistor Values
(for adjusting tweeter level) |
|
Desired Attenuation, dB
|
Rs
|
Rp
|
|
1
|
0.9
|
65.6
|
|
2
|
1.6
|
30.9
|
|
3
|
2.3
|
19.4
|
|
4
|
3
|
13.7
|
|
5
|
3.5
|
10.3
|
|
6
|
4
|
8
|
|
7
|
4.4
|
6.5
|
|
8
|
4.8
|
5.3
|
|
9
|
5.4
|
4.4
|
|
10
|
5.5
|
3.7
|
About the Designer
This fantastic
"T-Line" project was submitted by Dave Brown (AKA
"dB" on the PE
Tech Talk Board) of Placerville, CA. Thanks Dave, we appreciate
it!
Dave's
home page
|